The best pizza NYC Brooklyn scene is crowded, but the real answer comes down to a handful of legendary pizzerias and a few newer favorites. Whether you want a coal-oven pie, a Sicilian square, or a dollar-ish slice, these are the places that earn the hype.
Brooklyn has more pizza opinions than blocks. We narrowed it to seven spots that people actually travel for, with the kind of details you’ll want before you commit to the subway.
Here are the 7 spots serving some of the best pizza NYC Brooklyn, whether you’re after history, a square slice, or a date-night pie.
Di Fara Pizza – 🏆 Bowery Beat Editor Top Choice
Address: 1424 Avenue J, Brooklyn, NY 11230
Phone: (718) 258-1367
Style: Old-school NY round pies and square slices
Vibe: Pilgrimage energy, small and no-frills
Price: $$
Website: difarapizzany.com
Midwood is a trek, and Di Fara knows you’ll make it anyway. This is the pizzeria that turned Brooklyn pizza into a pilgrimage, and for the best pizza NYC Brooklyn has to offer, it’s still the benchmark.
Expect basil snipped over the top and olive oil drizzled on at the end. Expect a wait too, because every pie gets that personal treatment.
Go on a weekday afternoon, bring patience, and don’t skip the square slice.
L&B Spumoni Gardens
Address: 2725 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11223
Phone: (718) 449-1230
Style: Sicilian square slices with sauce on top of the cheese
Vibe: Casual, sprawling, very Bensonhurst
Price: $
Website: spumonigardens.com
The sauce goes on top of the cheese here, which tells you everything about how much this place cares about convention. The square slice is thick, crisp-bottomed, and ridiculously good.
Finish with a cup of spumoni from the counter. That’s the whole point of the name.
Lucali
Address: 575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
Phone: (718) 858-4086
Style: Thin-crust pies and calzones, candlelit
Vibe: Date-night cozy, always packed
Price: $$$
Website: lucali.com
Carroll Gardens’ candlelit pizza institution. It’s cash only and BYOB (confirm before you go), and the line starts early, so show up with a bottle and plenty of time.
The pies are thin, blistered, and loaded with fresh basil. It’s a splurge by pizza standards, but it earns it.
Roberta’s
Address: 261 Moore St, Brooklyn, NY 11206
Phone: (718) 417-1118
Style: Wood-fired Neapolitan-leaning pies
Vibe: Bushwick cool, loud and fun
Price: $$
Website: robertaspizza.com
The spot that proved a pizzeria in a Bushwick industrial block could become a global name. The crust is chewy and charred in all the right places.
Come hungry and in a group so you can order a few pies. If you’re also bar-hopping, pair it with our guide to the best bars in Bushwick.
Luigi’s Pizza
Address: 686 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Phone: (718) 499-3857
Style: Classic NY slices
Vibe: Neighborhood slice shop, no frills
Price: $
Park Slope’s slice counter went viral for a reason: Luigi’s keeps it simple and gets the fundamentals right. The slice is thin, foldable, and exactly what you want at 9 p.m. on a Tuesday.
It’s the cheapest way to eat some of the best pizza NYC Brooklyn can offer. Pair it with a walk through South Slope.
Totonno’s
Address: 1524 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224
Phone: (718) 372-8606
Style: Coal-oven pies, old Coney Island school
Vibe: Historic, laid-back, seaside
Price: $$
One of the oldest pizzerias in the country, a few blocks from the Coney Island boardwalk. The coal oven gives the crust a char you can’t fake.
Make a beach day of it. Pizza first, then the boardwalk.
L’industrie Pizzeria
Address: 254 S 2nd St, Brooklyn, NY 11211
Style: Slice shop with creative toppings
Vibe: Williamsburg line, worth the line
Price: $
The Williamsburg slice shop that built a cult following. The burrata slice is the order, and the crust holds up under it.
Lines move fast. Eat it standing on the sidewalk like a New Yorker.
So, What Is the Best Pizza NYC Brooklyn Has?
Finding the best pizza NYC Brooklyn really depends on what you’re in the mood for.
If you want a legend, Di Fara has it.
If you want a square slice, L&B Spumoni Gardens delivers.
If you want date night, Lucali is hard to beat.
If you want the slice everyone’s talking about, Luigi’s is leading the conversation.
There isn’t one single answer, and that’s kind of the point.
Hungry for more? Browse our Food & Drink guides or see where to go for late night food in Brooklyn. Grab a napkin and go.
