The best vegan NYC pizza comes down to one thing: a crust and a cheese that don’t make you miss the dairy. New York has finally gotten good at this, and you no longer have to settle for a sad slice with a shrug of vegan mozzarella on top.
This is our short list of the best vegan pizza in NYC, from fully plant-based shops to old-school slice joints that quietly do a great vegan pie. If you’re also hunting for the best pizza in Brooklyn, a few of these overlap.
Here are 8 spots serving some of the best vegan NYC pizza, whether you’re after a late-night slice, a sit-down pie, or a vegan pepperoni roll in Queens.
Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop – 🏆 Bowery Beat Editor Top Choice
Address: 110 Franklin St, Brooklyn, NY 11222
Style: New York-style and square slices with vegan options
Vibe: Casual slice counter in Greenpoint
Price: $ (by the slice)
Website: pauliegee.com
Paulie Gee’s is the rare serious pizza name that treats vegan slices as a real menu item, not a footnote. The Vegan Grandma, built on a coconut-oil based NUMU mozzarella, is the one to order.
It’s a slice counter, so go in expecting to eat standing up or on the walk down Franklin Street. Menus rotate, so check what’s vegan the day you go.
Green Oven Pizza
Address: 707 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019
Phone: (212) 245-6260
Style: Plant-based and gluten-free pizza
Vibe: Hell’s Kitchen takeout and delivery spot, open very late
Price: $$
Website: greenovenpizza.getsauce.com
Green Oven is fully plant-based, which makes it the easiest call on this list if your group includes a strict vegan and a skeptic. The cheese pull is the whole pitch on their TikTok, and honestly, it holds up.
Their site lists hours of 10 AM to 3 AM daily, which makes this a legitimately good post-Broadway option in the 40s and 50s.
Scarr’s Pizza
Address: 35 Orchard St, New York, NY 10002
Phone: (212) 334-3481
Style: Old-school New York pies, with a vegan pie made with NUMU cheese
Vibe: Retro Lower East Side pizzeria with a full bar
Price: $$
Scarr’s is famous for milling its own flour, which is exactly why its vegan pie belongs in any best vegan NYC pizza conversation. The crust does the heavy lifting here.
Pair it with a drink from the bar and you’ve got a vegan date night that doesn’t feel like a compromise. Confirm the vegan pie is on the current menu before you commit.
Unregular Pizza
Address: 135 Fourth Ave, New York, NY 10003
Style: Slice shop with vegan margherita and mushroom slices
Vibe: Quick, friendly, near Union Square
Price: $ (by the slice)
Website: unregularpizza.com
Unregular has a following among vegans who rave about the crust and the service, and reviewers say the vegan slices tend to sell out. Go early.
It also has a second location on Essex Street on the Lower East Side, per a delivery listing, so check which branch is closer.
Double Zero
Address: 65 Second Ave, New York, NY 10003
Style: Plant-based personal pies from a wood-burning oven, from chef Matthew Kenney
Vibe: East Village sit-down with a more upscale bent
Price: $$
If you want a knife-and-fork meal, this is the best vegan NYC pizza for it. Start with the margherita, then try the artichoke pie or the spicy arrabiata.
Heads up: the restaurant has changed hands and names over the past year or so, so confirm it’s open and what it’s called before you head over.
San Remo Pizzeria & Restaurant
Address: 56-01 Myrtle Ave, Ridgewood, NY 11385
Phone: (718) 497-1903
Style: Neighborhood pizzeria with a huge vegan menu
Vibe: Classic Queens red-sauce joint
Price: $
San Remo is the underdog on this list. A normal-looking Ridgewood pizzeria that happens to offer vegan round pies, Sicilian squares, pasta, heroes, and vegan pepperoni, sausage, and meatballs.
It’s the best vegan pizza in NYC for anyone who wants the full red-sauce experience without the dairy.
Screamer’s Pizzeria
Address: 685 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225
Style: Fully vegan pizza shop
Vibe: Crown Heights counter spot
Price: $
Screamer’s is the city’s original all-vegan slice shop, known for the grandma pie and the Buffalo pie. Its original Greenpoint shop closed in 2023, so make sure you’re heading to the Crown Heights location.
Seating is limited, so plan to take it to go.
Zazzy’s Pizza
Address: Lower East Side, with other Manhattan locations
Style: New York-style vegan cheese pie made with NUMU mozzarella
Vibe: Slice-shop energy, easy and quick
Price: $
Zazzy’s makes a vegan cheese pie and a gluten-free vegan version, plus meatless meatballs for the heroes. It’s a solid default when you’re in Manhattan and don’t want to plan.
Check their site for the closest shop, since we couldn’t confirm every address.
So, What Is the Best Vegan NYC Pizza?
Finding the best vegan NYC pizza really depends on what you’re in the mood for.
If you want a proper sit-down pie, Double Zero delivers.
If you want a slice you can eat on the walk, Paulie Gee’s is hard to beat.
If you want the cheese pull, Green Oven is leading the conversation.
If you want the full red-sauce experience, San Remo has it.
There isn’t one single answer, and that’s kind of the point. For more food picks, browse our Food & Drink guides, then go eat something.
